Andrew Rosenfeldt Guilty Of Being ‘stupid’ But Not Murder, Defence Says In Closing Arguments

Closing arguments began Friday successful nan second-degree execution proceedings of Andrew Rosenfeldt, nan Saskatoon man accused of sidesplitting his partner successful 2022.

The victim, 20-year-old Nykera Brown, was changeable successful her location astatine 124 Avenue P South connected Nov. 15, 2022.

Without impervious of who pulled nan trigger, arguments person turned to debating whether it was a lawsuit of termination aliases homicide.

Throughout nan trial, Rosenfeldt has told aggregate different versions of what happened that night. Defence lawyer Chris Murphy admits Rosenfeldt lied to constabulary aggregate times while successful custody and hid nan would-be execution limb but that isn’t impervious capable that he killed Brown.

Murphy argues that Rosenfeldt is blameworthy of being stupid, but not of murder.

In closing arguments, he said each nan grounds proves Brown was unhappy pinch her life and died pursuing ongoing struggles pinch intelligence health.

The Crown argues that location is capable impervious of maltreatment successful nan narration and grounds of Brown fighting for a amended life to judge Rosenfeldt is guilty.

Murphy points to nan Crown’s grounds of maltreatment arsenic a origin for Brown’s intelligence wellness issues, referring to respective of Brown’s diary entries.

He outlined her penning connected Rosenfeldt’s aggressions while struggling pinch impotence, arsenic grounds of an unsatisfactory relationship.

Murphy besides referenced nan mates fighting complete Rosenfeldt’s infidelity connected societal media.

Trending Now

The Crown based on nan 2 things Brown would dice for were her pack affiliations and her baby, not Rosenfeldt, quoting different introduction that reads, “I ever propulsion myself retired of these emotions earlier I drown.”

The Crown pointed to aggregate occasions wherever Brown reached retired to family and friends during intelligence wellness crises, and said she was fighting for a amended life for herself by deciding to time off Rosenfeldt.

The Crown besides based on that Brown telling Rosenfeldt she was leaving for bully during her last telephone telephone from 8:11 to 8:14 p.m. nan nighttime of her decease incited a hopeless enactment of unit from Rosenfeldt.

Murphy confirmed that Rosenfeld called constabulary astatine 8:13 and 55 seconds that night, leaving conscionable seconds of that nighttime still unknown.

The Crown’s closing statement will proceed connected Monday.