Why A Kyler Murray–tua Tagovailoa Qb Swap Makes Sense

The NFL waste and acquisition deadline came and went, but it’s ne'er excessively early to look astatine imaginable trades for adjacent year, particularly astatine nan backmost position. 

Kyler Murray and Tua Tagovailoa could some usage a alteration of scenery. It wouldn’t beryllium a bad thought if nan Cardinals and Dolphins swapped quarterbacks to footwear disconnected nan 2026 offseason. Drafting a backmost adjacent twelvemonth mightiness nary longer beryllium nan champion way because there’s nary surefire imaginable astatine nan position, and there’s now talk of nan ’27 people being better. 

Instead of forcing different twelvemonth pinch these 2 inconsistent quarterbacks, nan Dolphins and Cardinals should person them waste and acquisition places and go span quarterbacks. And there’s besides a bully chance that a waste and acquisition could revive their careers. We’ve seen grounded first-round quarterbacks excel aft changing teams, from Baker Mayfield to Sam Darnold to now Daniel Jones. 

A backmost switch besides worked good for nan Rams and Lions backmost successful 2021, erstwhile they executed nan blockbuster involving Matthew Stafford and Jared Goff.  

And I committedness this is nan past NFL Fact aliases Fiction this play that mentions Murray and Tagovailoa either being benched aliases moved. But nan past clip that occurred, Tagovailoa threw 4 touchdowns against nan Falcons earlier crashing again nan pursuing week against nan Ravens. 

Dolphins backmost Tua Tagovailoa faces an uncertain early successful Miami, pinch nan squad struggling and nan apt shakeup pinch nan beforehand agency and coaching staff. / Dale Zanine-Imagn Images

Manzano’s view: Fact 

It’s becoming progressively apt that Tagovailoa and Murray will header this upcoming offseason’s backmost carousel. Tagovailoa has struggled for much than a twelvemonth now, while Murray mightiness person been softly demoted by nan Cardinals (3–5) this week after Jacoby Brissett was named nan starter against nan Seahawks. 

It wouldn’t beryllium a bad thought for these 2 quarterbacks to waste and acquisition places. For each his flaws, Tagovailoa has astatine slightest shown that he’s tin capable to get nan shot to his playmakers, which Murray has grounded to do pinch second-year wide receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. On nan different broadside of this scenario, Murray mightiness use from a alteration successful coaching philosophy, whether that’s pinch Mike McDaniel aliases a different coach successful Miami.  

It doesn’t bode good for Murray that coach Jonathan Gannon instantly named Brissett nan starter for nan Week 10 matchup successful Seattle. Last week, Gannon waited until nan extremity of nan week to make nan announcement, giving Murray a chance to beryllium he’s fresh to play aft weeks of dealing pinch an injured foot. Now there’s talk of Murray needing much clip to heal, which could besides beryllium a bully measurement of saying nan 2019 No. 1 prime isn’t technically being benched.  

There was nary request to hold because Brissett has fixed this discourtesy a spark. And if Gannon gets fired, possibly a caller coach would for illustration to support Murray. Murray is not a fresh for really Gannon and violative coordinator Drew Petzing want to run connected nan field. 

Now, Murray and Tagovailoa each person lucrative contracts, pinch plentifulness of guaranteed money remaining for 2026. With a potential lackluster backmost class adjacent year, it mightiness beryllium amended for these 2 teams to commencement 1 of these veterans adjacent twelvemonth and return their chances pinch nan ’27 draught class. Contracts get swapped, and nan 2 signal-callers get a caller start. If it doesn’t activity out, some tin beryllium released nan pursuing offseason.

If nan Dolphins aren’t interested, Murray could still person a bully magnitude of suitors because nan scouts aren’t precocious connected adjacent year’s draft. The Jets are focused connected 2027 aft nan 2 scatter trades they made connected Tuesday, sending Sauce Gardner to Indianapolis and Quinnen Williams to Dallas. Murray’s statement isn’t arsenic large arsenic Tagovailoa’s and his athleticism could adhd different constituent to an offense. 

For nan Dolphins (2–7), they mightiness person to trot retired Tagovailoa again until they’re capable to move his contract. However, they don’t request to unit this business different year. And they tin telephone Arizona and inquire astir Murray. 

Bills made a correction not executing a waste and acquisition astatine nan deadline 

Manzano’s view: Fiction 

The Bills (6–2) person drawn immoderate disapproval for opinionated pat astatine nan waste and acquisition deadline, but they didn’t person galore options. All nan difference-makers that were dealt connected Tuesday came from nan Jets, a section rival of nan Bills.

It mightiness person costs Buffalo much first-round picks than what Dallas and Indianapolis paid for Williams and Gardner, respectively, to unit New York to waste and acquisition those prima players wrong nan AFC East. And it’s difficult not to blasted nan Bills for not being fierce connected a wide receiver aft nan minimal results they sewage from nan Amari Cooper midseason waste and acquisition past year.  

Rashid Shaheed is a standout playmaker, but his accomplishment group is akin to Khalil Shakir’s. Adding Jakobi Meyers’s versatility would person benefited Buffalo’s offense, but it would person been challenging for nan Bills to lucifer what Jacksonville gave up to get Meyers. Trading 2 Day 3 picks was a steep value for possibly a No. 3 aliases No. 4 pass-catching action successful Buffalo—let’s not place nan value tight ends that play pinch Josh Allen.

So it’s not truthful bad that nan Bills are moving guardant pinch nan roster GM Brandon Beane constructed successful nan offseason. The Chiefs, Broncos and Patriots are doing nan same. And nan Colts are acold from being viewed arsenic nan dense favourite successful nan AFC, moreover aft landing Gardner. It won’t beryllium easy, but nan Bills still person a beardown chance of yet getting to a Super Bowl pinch Allen. 

Manzano’s view: Fact

It wasn’t an mishap that I didn’t mention nan Chargers (6–3) successful nan imaginable teams nan Bills person to interest astir successful nan postseason. 

Jim Harbaugh’s squad was built astir nan violative line, a beardown moving crippled and Justin Herbert. Two of those areas will now return a monolithic deed aft Alt sustained a season-ending ankle injury. He’s that important to L.A., and it was noticeable erstwhile he missed 3 consecutive games earlier this season. 

Now Herbert has to play astatine an elite level to get this squad into nan playoffs and will person to do it pinch a patchwork violative statement and a short-handed backfield that whitethorn not spot galore sizable moving lanes successful nan coming weeks. However, the waste and acquisition for versatile violative lineman Trevor Penning and nan return of Omarion Hampton, who’s moving his measurement backmost from an ankle injury, could thief Los Angeles successful nan coming weeks.

The Chargers still look for illustration a bully stake to make nan postseason, but we each saw what a subpar violative statement did for Herbert successful past year’s disfigured wild-card nonaccomplishment against nan Texans. 

Browns protect extremity Myles Garrett has been ascendant passim his profession successful Cleveland. / Jeff Lange / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

Browns did nan correct point holding onto Myles Garrett

Manzano’s view: Fiction 

It would beryllium ironic if nan Jets hap to draught nan backmost that nan Browns had an oculus connected adjacent twelvemonth aliases successful 2027.

The Browns weren’t bold capable to waste and acquisition Garrett and summation much draught superior to springiness themselves nan champion changeable astatine landing a franchise backmost successful nan coming years. Now nan Jets person nan elasticity to move astir nan draught bid to get nan backmost they want because they traded Gardner and Williams astatine nan deadline. 

New York woke up and realized it wasn’t going anyplace pinch those 2 players and made nan sensible determination to waste and acquisition them and ignite a caller rebuild, possibly a due one, because teams won’t get acold without a franchise quarterback. 

The Browns will person only themselves to blasted if this latest rebuild doesn’t spell anyplace again because different teams drafted nan amended quarterbacks. But, astatine slightest Garrett will get his double-digit sacks for a fewer much years.

More NFL connected Sports Illustrated